Losing C.J. Hicks and Malik Hartford to transfers stung more than anyone expected for Ohio State in 2025. With new redshirt rules coming too late, the Buckeyes were forced to sideline talented players to save eligibility, sacrificing crucial depth during the season’s biggest moments. The team looked unbeatable on paper, but when it mattered most, a lack of experienced backups showed. Fans are left wondering: Should coaches have risked burning redshirts for a better shot at a title, or was protecting the future the right call? How would you have handled it? #Sports #OhioState #Buckeyes