What Do You Gift a Man Who Looks Shy but Smells Like Drama?

He wears glasses. Reads Murakami. Wears beige sweaters. But also—checks his reflection every five minutes and definitely knows he’s cute. I want to get him a fragrance. Something low-key... but not really. Like, “Oops did I smell amazing?” vibes. Any recs for colognes that whisper on the outside and scream on the inside? Help. 🙃 #beauty #fragrance #giftingmen