American Idol fans are buzzing after Josh King was eliminated, with many claiming the judges saved the wrong person. The real twist? Josh reportedly told the judges to save Mattie instead of himself, sparking debate over whether he gave up his spot in a selfless move. Some say Mattie didn't deserve the save, while others are praising Josh's sweet gesture. The fandom is split: was this a true act of kindness or a missed chance for real talent? #AmericanIdol #JoshKing #MattiePruitt #IdolDrama #RealityTV #Entertainment