Carrie Underwood’s Idol Tears 😢

Carrie Underwood really struggled with the first big elimination as a new American Idol judge, and fans are buzzing about how emotional she got sending six contestants home. Some think her nostalgia from winning 20 years ago is making it harder, while others say she needs to toughen up for live TV. Did she let her feelings sway the picks, especially with Zaylie Windsor (her Taylor Swift comparison) getting cut? The fandom is split! #AmericanIdol #CarrieUnderwood #IdolDrama #FandomDebate #Entertainment